IT Outsourcing: Economic and Policy Analysis
TOPIC
Economic and technological incentives to outsource, and government policies that can affect IT outsourcing rates.
ABSTRACT
We investigate the causes and effects of recent increased IT outsourcing to lower-waged countries. In the first section, we will examine the economic considerations to outsourcing IT work abroad. The economic considerations include a cost/benefit analysis of the impact that outsourcing has on an individual firm and on the US market as a whole. This section will provide insight into the economic incentives to outsource or not. Delving into the economics of outsourcing has important implications for policy because policy can alter decision making of whether to outsource or not by changing incentives. (Subtopic 2). Outsourcing is a recent phenomena, and there is little empirical evidence on what the best course of governmental action is. Therefore, we take past public policies in response to outsourcing and discuss whether a correlation exists between the two. Accordinlgy,the research methodology will be mainly based on the comparative case study.(U.S. vs. France vs. India) We will also analyze how Bush Administration incoporated the point of view of economists as well as the politics in the U.S. labor market. In the end, we will examine the possible public policies and discuss its feasibility, followed by cost-benefit analysis of each policy.
SUB-TOPICS
1) Economic Considerations To Outsourcing - Pros/Cons
- costs/benefits of outsourcing (looking at theory of comparative advantage, supply/demand, costs of transfer, etc)
- discussion of India and why the US chooses to outsource there
- Compare cost of living in India
- operational costs in the US v. costs in India
- foreign currency benefits (pay local workers in money from local product sales)
- can allow US companies to avoid layoffs
- if costs savings allow company to grow, then company can hire US workers in other areas (marketing, biz dev, etc.)
- outsourcing may lower employee morale which in turn reduces productivity
2) Non-economic Considerations To Outsourcing - Pros/Cons
- Analysis of what is typically outsourced and what is not
- Quality of outsourced work
- Outsourcing and the impact on internal employees (morale, job opps, etc.)
- Risks in outsourcing (IT core competancies, PR, etc.)
- Use of outsourcing to avoid overhiring during cyclic business upswings
- Allows for rapid ramp up of work force to handle strategic projects. Either (1) using outsourced workers for the strategic projects or (2) using outsourced workes for core projects and freeing US-based workers for strategic projects
- Effects of outsourcing on US innovation (investing in R&D)
3) Analysis Of Existing Public Policies
- Dicussion of outsourcing in the traditional sense (blue-collar jobs) and past government policies towards them.
- Past administrative policies (Reagan, Bush Sr., Clinton)
- Acknowledge that IT outsourcing is a recent phenomena; lack of empirical evidence
- Are these differences detrimental to the comparison?
- Analysis of public policies in general that lead to outsourcing.
- Policies that have affected outsourcing from Silicon Valley companies.
- Protectionism as a "double edged sword"
- France's recent announcement of tax breaks and other incentives.
- Discuss the differences between France and US outsourcing--industry.. are they similiar?
4) US Public Policies To Manage Outsourcing
- The viewpoint of Bush Administration about IT outsourcing/insourcing
- The viewpoint of U.S. economists/corporations about IT outsoucring
- The viewpoint of other stakeholders
- The political economy of outsoucring policy, trade policy: costs and benefits
- Discussion about possible public policies:
a. Improve high school math and science to keep US competitive internationally
b. Modify college curriculums to provider training for jobs that will continue to be
needed in an outsourced economy (project mgmt, architects, etc.)
c. Additional government spending to university R&D projects to produce higher/highly skilled
workers
d. Tax breaks to US corporations for keeping employees in US
e. Procurement
f. Trade agreements
g. Visas (this could be a whole topic to itself).
GROUP MEMBERS
Mandy Chang, UC Berkeley, mandy_c@berkeley.edu User: mandy_c(subtopic 3)
Aamir Alavi, UC Berkeley, aalamir@berkeley.edu User: aamiralavi(subtopic 1)
Brad Struss, UW, bradstr@cs.washington.edu User: bradstr(subtopic 2)
Jeongsoo Kim, UC Berkeley, jk37@berkeley.edu user: jk37(subtopic4)
SOURCES
"Offshoring" Service Jobs: Bane or Boon and What to Do?
How Outsourcing Creates Jobs for Americans
Outsourcing, Offshoring, and Globalization
Offshore Outsourcing Resource Center
[http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2004/03/07/MNGRT5G2C11.DTL Offshoring's giant target: the Bay Area Silicon Valley could face export of 1 in 6 jobs -- worst in nation]
Global IT Sourcing: Impacts and Implications for Washington State
Dell's dirty words: Outsourcing, proprietary
Relocating the Back Office, Economist
White House Under Fire for Outsourcing Proposal
[http://www.opednews.com/kelly0204_clinton_policies.htm The Sooner Democrats Disassociate Themselves From Clinton’s Trade Policies, the Better; Otherwise, Republicans Will Turn Their Best Economic Argument Against Them]
Global software outsourcing: The solution to the IT skills gap
[http://www.senate.gov/~clinton/news/2004/2004211549.html Clinton Calls on Senate to Support Amendment Repudiating Bush Administration Support for Sending American Jobs Overseas]
